Rachel and I talk about all the great TV that Mike Schur has been up to his elbows in over the years. First aired on Facebook Live on May 4, 2020
Topics discussed: Taika Waititi’s still as of 2025 untitled star wars project, The Mandalorian, Parks & Recreation, Good Place, Brooklyn 99, and The Office(s)
The first of our Lost Episodes series! Technically they haven’t been lost yet but with Facebook removing all old live videos at the end of the month, we wanted to make sure there was a home for our COVID-era episodes, starting with our musings on all things both musical and theatrical from April 27, 2020!
Topics discussed: Crazy Ex Girlfriend, The Sondheim Celebration, Les Mis, Hamilton, Hadestown, SIX, Come From Away, Wicked, Parade, Urinetown, Sweeney Todd, Phantom, Zip!, Into the Woods, Free Solo, 127 Hours, Avenue Q, Guys and Dolls, Oklahoma, Cinderella, Sound of Music, Gigi, Gypsy, Beetlejuice, Mama Mia, Galavant, Glee, Greatest Showman, La La Land, Buffy Musical, That Song In Every Musical That No One Likes, and Aladdin
There are many games where players move armies around a map to seize and hold territory in order to secure victory. These games can have a King of the Mountain energy where obvious winners inspire other players to set aside their differences to unite in dragging them down or neck and neck players try to convince everyone else at the table that their rival is the real danger, not them. From classics like Risk to Diplomacy to big chunky wargames like Twilight Imperium or Game of Thrones, these games are often big, long, affairs where hours of planning and maneuvering are rewarded or not. War of Whispers by contrast is a fast game lasting only 4 rounds and around an hour and yet in that time it manages to capture a lot of the elements that makes those larger games so compelling while also subverting them.
In War of Whispers, players are not representing the different empires and kingdoms at war but rather the secret societies, cults, and conspiracies maneuvering in the shadows and manipulating these larger forces. They’ll share control of the kingdoms and try to manipulate the wars to their favour.
At the start of the game players randomly shuffle their ranking of the different kingdoms that will determine how many points they’ll gain or lose depending on how the war shakes out. In this way the game has more in common with gambling on a horse race or buying stocks than with just straight up trying to grab Kamchatka before anyone else. These rankings are secret and keeping that information privileged helps prevent your rivals from sabotaging your goals. However, empires fall and sometimes it pays to switch bets so between rounds, players can swap their rankings between two kingdoms but in so doing they flip over their tiles and reveal what their new rankings are.
Every round, players assign agents to the different officers tasked with running this war which gives them the ability muster troops, draw cards, and attack rival kingdoms. There are no restrictions on how many agents from which factions can be on any given kingdom so you can very well see a turn where one player raises an army and another player sends that army in the complete opposite direction of where the first player wanted. Combat couldn’t be simpler with armies canceling each other out, no dice needed. The cards allow players to swap out actions or move armies around unexpectedly or can even cause dramatic upheavals.
As the game goes on, more and more agents get added and control gets more complicated as everyone gets a better idea who is in favor and who isn’t. By the end some kingdoms will be mighty empires astride their conquered rivals or burnt out war zones, or colonized husks of their former selves. When the smoke clears, players reveal all their rankings and score based on how many cities the kingdoms control.
War of Whispers is a deeply clever game that plays remarkably differently every time we bring it to table. There isn’t a great deal of table talk because so much of the game is trying to misdirect and hide your intentions although it can be a lot of fun to roleplay the hapless kingdoms who just can’t seem to catch a break. If players have similarly ranked kingdoms they can be unknowingly working together. Similarly when one kingdom is everyone’s bottom pick that creates hilarious devastation. It feels almost like a meta-war game with the grand schemes and bold tactics being reduced to opportunistic sabotage and sudden betrayals. The cards create the most unpredictable chaos and I can see them frustrating players with the way they can upend things but I appreciate the threat they pose and the arms race of collecting one’s own cards to have on hand to even things out.
I have the deluxe version which comes with the larger pieces which makes the board pop and apparently makes reading the board state a lot easier. It also adds additional cards that provide more variety. Not a deal breaker but definitely adds to the game experience. Whichever version, I have had great success putting this in front of my friends and heartily recommend.
Folks who have been following this blog know I’m a sucker for a strong theme that grips the imagination and tells a story. Given that, one would be forgiven for assuming I hanker for big campaign or legacy games but fortunately for my wallet that isn’t the case. With the exception of a semi-burgled copy of Pandemic Legacy a friend left at my house and King’s Dilemma I’ve largely stayed away from Legacy games. When I learned about Earthborne Rangers and the way it carried players through a story while also being a game of exploration and ecological management I jumped at the chance.
The game uses cards, tokens, and a campaign book with different read-aloud entries to tell the story of rangers in a far future where humans have opted to live in greater harmony with the environment largely by leaving it alone for centuries before returning to the surface to explore and see how nature has healed. It’s comparable to a cozier Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind. Players take on the roles of 1 to 4 rangers with skills, gears, and personality aspects that they draw on and play to overcome challenges, connect with the people, beings, and places they come across, and travel around this lush and living world.
Like the best dresses, this game comes with pockets! The creators not only wanted to explore ecological and sustainability themes in their game but produced it to be as environmentally friendly as possible. This leads to an incredible economy of component that feels slick and flexible and robust without needing armies of plastic. With a map, a book, some cards, and an assortment of tokens, players have all the tools they need for adventure and exploration. The storage system neatly allows for quick and easy set up and take down and the game state can be saved to allow for resuming the campaign easily without needing a ton of administration.
At the start of the campaign, players construct a personal Ranger deck either on their own or using a structured Prologue the campaign book provides that walks them through all the different types of cards that go into their deck (as a secret third way, you can also use the premade decks so you can jump right in to the action.) Decks are made up of personality cards, backgrounds that represent your early training, specialities that determines your Role and act like RPG classes, and then an outside interest that can be drawn from any of the starting cards to allow some flexibility and customizing. Along with these decks rangers also choose an Aspect card with 1 to 3 points allocated to four main stats that will get used to determine what all they can do – Awareness, Spirit, Fitness, and Focus.
The campaign is played out in Days which corresponds roughly with an individual game session. At the start of the Day, players draw their hand from their Ranger deck and put energy tokens on their Aspect card. Based on where they last ended their campaign they set out a Location card and create a Path deck based on the environment they’ve been traveling through (woods, grasslands, swamp, mountains, etc) adding in cards based on their location or Valley cards which add random challenges and opportunities. The Path deck will have obstacles, plants, animals, and other humans who will help or hinder the rangers as they travel from location to location. Based on the day, there will be a weather card that will also impact the Rangers as they travel. Finally players will shuffle and set up the Challenge deck that both adds some chance to Tests as well as triggering Challenge Effects on cards already in play.
The Day is broken up into rounds where players will draw new Path cards and play them either directly in front of them (Within Reach) or between them and the current Location card (Along the Way) which represents the range of the particular card and who it can impact. Players can interact freely with cards within reach but if they try to interact with cards further away they run the risk of getting Fatigue. On their turn, players can spend energy tokens from their Aspect card to either play cards from their hands or to attempt Tests on the cards already in play.
Tests are carried out by spending the relevant token and discarding cards with symbols that match the Test and then drawing a Challenge card to see if the total is equal to or higher than the Test’s difficulty. Tests usually result in placing Progress or Harm tokens on different cards in order to Clear them out of the way which makes it easier to interact with other cards, reduces potentially harmful Challenge Effects, and can trigger mission or campaign entries. Players can choose to attempt any Test listed on cards in play or from the four basic tests that are available no matter what. These basic tests allow players to add Progress tokens to the current location in order to travel, adding Progress tokens to animals or humans, avoiding animals or humans by Exhausting (tapping) them, or drawing additional cards from their Ranger deck.
As the players run around they will frequently take Fatigue which pulls cards from their Ranger deck and sets it aside. Other cards and tests can Soothe Fatigue which places those set aside cards back in their hand. Players might also get Injured which increases the rate of Fatigue they take. If they take on too much Fatigue or Injuries and discard their deck down to the point that they can’t draw new cards, that can trigger the end of the Day so managing your health and Fatigue is important to be able to accomplish all you want in any game session. There is no death although taking too many Injuries can lead to players having to add Malady cards into their Ranger deck which junks it up going forward.
The round ends when all players have chosen to rest at which point they can choose to Travel if they have placed enough Progress tokens on their current location. This resets the play area and creates a new Path deck for players to explore. Regardless of if they travel or not, players then draw a card from their Ranger, put energy tokens back on their Aspect cards, Ready (untap) any Exhausted cards and then every player draws a new Path card and the next round begins.
This repeated round structure of spending energy, playing cards, making tests, managing Fatigue, and drawing new cards makes up the real core of the game and players have a lot of choices about how they want to interface with this world and it’s those choices that really bring this game to life. While the game can be played solo it really sings as a cooperative game as players can focus on areas where they’re more skilled and help one another where they aren’t as proficient. If one player is surrounded by snarling predators, their teammates can race to their rescue or leave them to work it out on their own.
A huge choice players have to make is when to move on to their next location as things may be getting dangerous and crowded but there might be fun people to interact with or missions that need to be worked on. Fulfilling these missions is a way to get Rewards which can be swapped into the Ranger deck to provide new options and show progress.
And sometimes you just want to play with your ferret.
I have thoroughly enjoyed my time with Earthborne Rangers both as a solo game and with friends although I much prefer the latter. The game has all the fun of a choose one’s own adventure game, a roleplaying game, and a clever card game. The way the game triggers different effects and the various cards interact makes it feel alive. When you have a play space full of predators and prey and plant life all feeding or moving each other makes this feel like an ecosystem that responds to your actions as well as living and breathing on its own. There isn’t as much of an emphasis on fighting and taming nature but the possibility for that is there which makes the choice to try to live in peace feel like a genuine and weighted decision.
I’m already eyeing the various expansions but given what all this game starts off with, I will hopefully be able to hold off for some time but I could spend a lot of time in this cozy future. The folks who make it also have great online resources like music, printable character sheets, and standalone adventures if you want a break from the full campaign or want to gently introduce friends to it. Superb game. Highly recommended.
I love Susanna Clarke’s collection of whimsical footnotes with attached novel and for a longer conversation on the subject I’ll direct you to episode 71 of this very podcast. But today I want to talk about Osprey Games’ 2019 adaptation of what may very well be my favorite book.
Players take on the role of magicians vying to be the greatest spell-slinger of the age through the traditional method of accruing thaumaturgic power – attending parties and acquainting themselves with notable persons. The game plays out over 12 rounds that take on peculiar characteristics by drawing from a deck of Marseilles cards. On a player’s turn, they will accrue books, bolster their magic, travel across London or Europe, attend soirees and/or meet notables, and then if able, carry out Feats of Magic. To win, players must both have a greater Magicianship than their rivals and the Gentleman with Thistledown Hair.
The first decision players must make every turn is which of their six actions they want to use or if they want to refresh those actions. Picking an action makes it unavailable on a future turn until they have been refreshed. These actions include acquiring books, teleporting around the map, or giving the magician more options for doing magic. This last one is incredibly important and requires planning.
The most potent way to increase Magicianship and thus win is to complete Feats of Magic. Each of those feats has a slot for a specific kind of magic (hills, rains, stones, birds, wind, and trees.) To place magic tokens on those slots, players discard Invitation and Introduction cards that have those matching symbols (foregoing social obligations to prioritize their magic.) However, they can only place tokens that match the ones present on this round’s Marseilles card unless they chose to use their action to study the specific magic. Books can also grant some flexibility and allow players to transmute one kind of token for another or increase the tokens they can place. If all the elements line up and a Feat can be accomplished then it adds to their Magicianship and grants them a spell which can do any number of fun things.
As well as improving their magical prowess, players can also increase their Prestige by hobnobbing with figures of note either from history or from the pages of Ms. Clarke’s novel. While Invitations can be spent to either claim Feats of Magic or Introduction cards, Introduction cards are spent to gain Prestige. Prestige determines turn order, breaks ties, and also unlocks bonuses on the player board like faster movement, extra Magicianship, drawing cards, and the like. As mentioned before both cards can also be discarded to eschew society and do magic.
I was surprised when I saw that Osprey was making this game. I associate them more with war games and painstakingly detailed military history books. Nevertheless I was excited to see how they tackled the book and found the end result very frustrating. There are a lot of things I love – the look and design, the way players navigate society and study. Ultimately however the whole thing falls flat for me.
A big problem is the threat of the Gentleman with Thistledown Hair. In theory I like the idea of there being a collective threat everyone has to deal with and forcing them to set aside their own issues to take on but that’s not what happens here. Players don’t work together but just try to scramble on their own to build up their score and hope against hope that it’s high enough to both beat out their colleagues and this abstract figure. I would have found it more interesting if players had to choose between their own ambition and the good of the table like Archipelago or Kill Doctor Lucky. It would have also been interesting if the GTH more directly messed with the game like throwing out obstacles or complications instead of just looming abstractly. At the end of the game, if he’s won, players just compare their own scores and take that as the moral victory even as they know they didn’t really win.
The other problem is the number of roadblocks and choke points this game throws up. To fulfill Feats you have to hope the Marseilles card *and* your hand of cards *and* your action wheel options all line up and when they don’t you’re just stuck feeling like you’ve wasted one of a frustratingly few turns. The choices feel less like getting to choose from a bunch of fun things and just picking something in hopes you don’t slam into the various barriers.
Finally, for a game about dueling magicians there is precious little interaction beyond a bit of racing for available Feats and Books. There could have been an interesting tension if players could cooperate or directly mess with each other, particularly in trying to deal with the GTH but aside from a few spells that can poke your rivals here and there, there’s nothing. Not even being on the same space allows for trading or stealing secrets. You’re essentially just doing parallel play which is ok but feels like a lost opportunity.
I’m going to keep poking at this game and hope I find something more fulfilling than I so far have but until then, I’m more likely to reach for the book than the game when I want to experience this world.
I’ve been giving a kiss to build a dream on since the 90s when I huddled around my friend Cal’s PC to check out this game he was raving about where you fought giant rats and delved into isometric vaults and in the intervening years I have played every iteration of Brian Fargo’s brain child, including the lamentable Brotherhood of Steel PS2 game. I even logged many hours in the iOS base builder that inspired today’s board game review. Fallout Shelter on the iPad is an ok time waster particularly when you’re in COVID isolation but it’s cardboard and plastic version is a genuine delight and one I come back to again and again.
The conceit of the game is that players are competing to improve their shelter, overcome threats, and raise morale to be chosen as Overseer at the end of the game. To accomplish this, players take turns placing workers on the limited spaces in their vault, collecting resources, trading them in for gear, new workers, and new rooms to provide more options for workers to exploit.
As with many resources management games, the real balance in Fallout Shelter comes from pursuing a better engine for collecting and using resources vs going for Happiness which is this games victory points resource. Luckily there are a lot of parallel choices that help both goals so it’s not as stark as a game like Dominion where victory points literally clog up your hands. Still, given the cramped quarters, limited options, and constant blocking by your so called fellow vault dwellers, the game starts with and maintains a decent tension scrambling for the scarce resources.
Resource tracking is managed very cleverly with a player board that has slots for Food, Water, and Power and players slide cubes into those slots to clearly see what they have in abundance or scarcity. Water is mostly used to venture outside the vault and procure gear which can help fight enemies, convert resources from one to another, or provide points at the end of the game. Food is necessary to attract more dwellers and gain more workers and thus more actions every round. Power’s main use is building new rooms which gives you more things to do, earns points, and once a player’s floor is completely filled in, triggers the end of the game.
Threats are these special see through cards that show up at the start of every round and block one of the spaces workers can be assigned to. Most of them are defeated by rolling dice but a few like fires and black outs, require spending resources to handle. Clearing out these threats often earns points or but also risks injuring workers and bringing them back to health is a tedious process that keeps you from being able to do anything else so often there’s negotiations about who’s dealing with the radscorpions in the cafeteria.
For a game based on an iPad game based on a classic videogame franchise, Fallout Shelter punches well above its weight and is a fun and quick game that ends before it gets too repetitive. It’s easy for one player to pull ahead and there can be some frustration in trying to catch up but because it’s relatively short, it doesn’t feel too demoralizing and there’s always the possibility a deathclaw will show up and ruin the frontrunner’s day. All in all it’s a pretty fun game and the metal lunch box it comes in makes it feel all the more…. SPECIAL.
I just finished Max Evry’s A Masterpiece in Disarray, an oral history about David Lynch’s Dune movie and everything that went well and wrong. As such it felt fitting to talk about Paul Dennen’s 2020 game Dune Imperium. While it was released in coordination with the newer Villeneuve movie, the game is likewise an ambitious chimera in keeping with the 1984 film.
Dune Imperium is a competitive game where players take on the roles of characters from the novels and movies sending out agents to curry favor with factions, petition the Landsraad, harvest and sell spice, and mobilize armies on the desert planet with a goal of earning the most points at the end of the game. This is carried out through worker placement where players take turns moving their agents to various spots on the board, activating them and denying access to other players. A twist of the game is that agents can only be sent to spaces unlocked by playing cards that are gained through a deck building mechanic.
Much of the game involves gathering resources and spending them to further your agenda. The three most visible resources are water, spice, and money which typically are gathered and spent to gain each other in turn. Water is needed to go into the desert to harvest spice, spice is needed to sell for money, money can be spent in a number of ways but mostly to manipulate the Landsraad and earn more troops, more agents, and so on. There are two other resources that are more abstract – Influence and Military Strength and they come into play at the end of the round.
There are three kinds of cards that get used in this game – Imperium cards, Intrigue cards and Conflict cards. The Imperium cards are the main cards used for moving agents across the board. Intrigue cards grant surprise bonuses throughout the game to points, resources, combat, etc. Conflict cards are flipped over at the top of the round and determine what the spoils of war will be this round.
Imperium cards are made up of a combination of locations they unlock, bonuses when played, and separate bonuses if saved and cashed in at the end of a round. This leads to constant calculations where players have to decide to use a card during their turn for an immediate use or save it for the end of the round for strategic purposes. One of the main end of round bonuses is gathering Influence which then gets spent to purchase new cards from the cards market. These cards are generally more powerful than the starting default cards and also allow players to hone their strategy by focusing on collecting Fremen cards, cards that improve harvesting spice, military cards, etc.
Much like with 7 Wonders, combat strength builds up over the round but doesn’t come into use until the end of the round. Players have troops either in reserve, in garrisons, or in the battlefield. On top of that, cards (both Intrigue and Imperial) can add combat strength. The stakes of the combat are determined at the top of the round, however, as the Conflict card is flipped and the rewards for coming in first, second, or third (only applicable in a 4 player game) are revealed. These rewards can be resources, points, intrigue cards, and later on, control of various locations on Arrakis. Juggling troops and cards and trying to determine when to go all in is a huge part of the game. Only certain locations allow you to add troops to the battlefield which depends on having the right cards to send agents to activate.
Finally there are the four factions and managing them and competing for their allegiance is a major path to victory. The Fremen provide water and troops. The Bene Gesserit give you Intrigue cards and help you weed out unhelpful cards from your deck. The Spacing Guild helps your agents go anywhere on the board and will trade troops for spice. And the Emperor gives you money and also will trade troops and Intrigue for spice. The more you visit these faction locations the higher their opinion of you grows and at certain levels you gain an Alliance which is a source of points and unlocks other powers.
This game mixes and matches familiar game concepts from across the hobby to create an Ixian ghola of a game that largely works but is a hard sell for casual gamer groups. Because of all the rules and the way they overlap and feed each other it can be very challenging trying to teach any individual part because everything is interconnected. Once you do grasp how everything works the actual game is… Fine? It flows pretty decently until you hit the many road blocks and choke points this game has set up. Want more troops? Better get money. Want money? Better get spice. Want spice? Well you better have water. Want water? Better have a card that lets you visit the Fremen. Don’t have any of that or find that other players have clogged up the locations you need? Then I guess you can’t do the things you want so better hope you draw better cards next round.
This tightness creates tension and cutthroat play which is in keeping with the source material and there are enough hidden cards and secret information so you’re always on your toes. As you race to gobble up resources, your attention is divided and choices have to be made about how best to pursue points and the game is at its best when you are torn between compelling actions and at its worst when you can’t really do anything because the cards and timing don’t add up.
There have been multiple expansions and even an updated edition that apparently address some of these concerns but I don’t feel compelled to spend more on this game although I was sore tempted when I found out the updated edition has a Christopher Walken card. Still, the game is fine but not one I feel folks absolutely need to rush out to get. I’m glad to have it sit next to my 1979 Avalon Hill Dune game on the shelf.
My 7 year old has become known for his love of games and so occasionally receives birthday or Christmas gifts to reflect this pastime he shares with his old man. Randy Flynn’s 2021 hex and tile laying game Cascadia was one such gift and as a good father, I have frequently yoinked it for games nights when folks request a game that’s got some substance but isn’t too complex
Cascadia falls into what we call the point salad category of games where players compete to earn the most points through a variety of means – in this case by placing hexes that create large contiguous biomes and by placing animal tiles in advantageous positions. Every turn players are given a limited option of 4 paired hexes and tiles and choose which to take and which to leave for their rivals to snap up. You only ever play hexes and tiles to your own play area so that snapping up is the only friction and interaction between players but it’s a doozy.
In any given round you are eyeing this small selection of tiles, sweating when a coveted bear or salmon pops its head out of the hefty bag of animals and you can feel both the elation when you get just what you need and the crushing despair when the player just to your right takes exactly what you needed like an avenging harpy. Luckily, because there are other routes to points, no turn feels wasted. This is aided by the speed of play which is beautifully quick as you only have a limited set of choices before you.
The game offers a few quirks to keep you on your toes. One is that if ever you are faced with three out of the four tiles being the same animal, you can wipe them away and draw three new ones. This is blessedly helpful when no-one wants foxes so the invisible hand of the free market clogs up the board with them. If ever there are four of the same animal, the wiping is automatic which helps speed things up. Another quirk are these cute little pinecones you’ll collect for putting animals on special hexes. These pinecones are worth points by themselves at the end of the game but they can also be spent to give you more flexibility when choosing tiles and hexes.
Cascadia is fast, breezy, and lovely to look at. Scoring takes a bit of time to work out and calculate but isn’t too much of a head scratcher and because there are so many paths to victory, you don’t have the frustration of seeing a clear winner early on and feeling left behind. Replayability is helped by the animal victory conditions being variable and players can choose from a selection of four victory options per animal or they can shuffle and trust fate. It’s a delightful game and I’m grateful my son has earned the ludological reputation he has and that I get to benefit from it.
