
There are games that sit in my tabs for months as I weigh the cost and potential to bring said game to the table and most times my self-control wins out over my imagined joy at spreading cardboard before my friends. Most times. With Old King’s Crown it was a long and valiantly fought struggle but as with a distressing number of games in my collection, it was the siren’s call of Shut Up And Sit Down that finally did me in and convinced me to add to cart and I’m so happy I gave in to temptation.
At the heart of Old King’s Crown is the simple game of War where the core mechanic is players playing cards and hoping theirs is the highest. This simple and readily understandable core is then wrapped up in baroque but not overly fiddly elements that create a truly phenomenal experience. The titular old king is dead and players each represent one faction vying to put its heir on the throne. To achieve this, they will gobble up Influence tokens which act as a sort of a victory point and whoever has the most after 4 to 6 rounds is the winner. Every round represents a year and is broken up into spring, summer, autumn, and winter with various actions available during each season.

Every faction comes with a deck of basic cards, a handful of advanced cards that can be purchased throughout the game, a player board, four tactics abilities, five supporters, and a chonky Herald token. The player board holds pieces as well as provides spaces for acquiring Kingdom Cards, letting you track your hand size, and indicating any of your faction’s special abilities. In the base game, the four factions are the Nobility which specializes in defense and slow plodding accrual of power, the Clans who favor speedy attacks and mobility in the field, the Uprising of the people who slink through the shadows and burn things down, and the Gathering who twist reality to their whim.

While the game kicks things off in spring I want to talk about summer first because that’s when Clashes occur and they are the real beating heart of the game. There are three Regions on the board and every summer players will secetly play three cards to vie for control of these Regions. Each of these Regions has two Locations which provide unique rewards to whichever faction wins. The first thing players will do is place their Herald piece in a specific location which if they win will provide them with bonus Influence. If two Heralds square off in the same Location then the victor gets their regular Influence and can steal Influence from the losers. While most of the game’s turn orders are determined by who has the most Influence, the order the Clashes occur in is chosen by whoever is last on the turn order track. One at a time, cards are revealed and then players have an opportunity to use special abilities before resolving the Clash and determining the winner. This happens in all three regions before we get to Autumn.
These clashes can be fierce and dynamic affairs. Cards can allow you to Ambush Regions by putting more cards into the fray or Retreat or Flank and pull out cards from a losing fight to do more good elsewhere. The most terrifying cards are the Deadly ones who Eliminate your opponenents’ unprotected cards, potentially removing them from the game. Figuring out which card to play to which Region is the core of every round and almost every other part of the game plays off or contributes to this decision.

Leaving summer and jumping back to spring, the first decision players have to make is how much to bid on acquiring Kingdom Cards. These are bonus cards that provide special abilities or unique actions. Whichever card a player uses to bid gets assigned to the card they acquire and is unavailable for the Summer clashes. After the first round, these bidding cards can also be used to burgle opponents’ Kingdom Cards if their higher than the one assigned to defend it. This can lead to these powerful artifacts and characters swapping allegiance at crucially unfortunate times. Players can only hold on to two of these Kingdom Cards on their player board at a time although some of them occasionally will get placed on a location or region as in the third picture above.
After bidding, Heralds and cards are placed in anticipation of the summer Clash and then players take their spring actions indicated by the green leaf symbol. The most common spring action shared by all players is assigning Supporters to different Regions to help in the coming clash. Each Supporter adds one strength and can lay claim to a Region even if the cards abandon the fight or are eliminated. Supporters get lost during winter and don’t come back to your player board so should be used carefully. In addition to playing supporters, players can make use of spring actions on their Kingdom Cards or Tactics cards. Tactics sit on a player board and exhause when used, often only getting used once per game although there are ways to get them back. Once all the spring actions are taken, we’re ready for war as described earlier.
After the clashes, we move into autumn which is a time for Governing, Journeying, and laying the groundwork for next year’s Clashes. In addition to fighting on the field of combat, players can spar in the various governing Councils pictured above. By slotting in cards to these Councils, players can earn more points, sneakily make use of locations’ special abilities, or reacquire lost Supporters. This is a subtle game and it can lock up cards you need for the war effort but can also be a useful dumping ground for ineffective or unwanted cards you don’t want clogging your deck.
Journeying is the main way of getting those advanced faction cards sitting tantalizingly close to your board. By journeying you either remove a card from the game or send it to the discard pile depending on whether they are a Pathfinder or not. This provides you with Lore which can be spent to acquire these advanced cards. Most of them will be more powerful versions of your regular cards but every faction has unique Headquarters which get added to your tableau and add new actions and abilities. If you manage to purchase all your advanced cards then any unspent Lore at the end of the game gets converted into Influence and added to your final score.
Much like the spring actions, players will also have autumn actions available to them through cards, Kingdom Cards, Tactics, or Governing Councils. One particularly tricky action is the Deploy action available on certain siege cards which allows you to roll up a siege engine into one of the Regions in preparation for next year’s Clashes. Other cards on the board might also have a Rally ability which allows you to put them back into your hand instead of going to the discard pile. After everyone has done what they can, winter comes as a clean-up phase when cards are discarded, Supporters are lost, and if you’ve reached your final round, victory is declared
The simple core of this game combined with the predictable rhythm of the seasons, and the completely unpredictable ways that cards will interact or players will bluff and feint make this game a fast and intense affair and one I want to get back to table as much as possible. The production design is gorgeous with every card acting almost like a creative writing prompt with rich imagery that is evocative and specific without being overwhelming. The game creates space for you to imagine your own world unfolding. In one clash, I sent my barely adolescent noble heir into the thick of battle only for him to wind up wandering alone through an abandoned ruin after losing the fight and all the other combatants leaving him to his own devices. In another scenario, the castle which the nobles had squatted in practically all game was finally overrun by cultists and nomads squaring off against each other before purging the Council of my sclerotic courtiers.
It’s a big box and the opening teach and first round can be intimidating but things click into place relatively easily and there are worlds of fun to be explored. I highly recommend.


















